There are those who claim that the tenure process should be decided as a result of academic review, not a petition, nor the voices and opinions of those who spent years of their lives at the university, nor the voices of El Haj's peers, for which we too make our offering.

And so, to show that there is a widely held opinion that Columbia University should deny tenure to Nadia Abu El Haj, we offer true academic reviews - written by experts who have studied Abu El Haj's dissertation in its entirety and found it - entirely lacking.

• Denial of Heritage

• Not Grounded in Fact

• Looking Glass Archaeology

• Applauding the Destruction of Joseph's Tomb at Columbia

• Postmodernizing Archaeology at Barnard

• Review of Facts on the Ground

• Bulldozer Archeology

• Nadia Abu El Haj and the Use of Evidence